| 1996 |
8-6 |
Jeanie Elgersma |
| 1997 |
15-3-2 |
Jeanie Elgersma |
| 1998 |
13-6 |
Jeanie Elgersma |
| 1999 |
12-5 |
Steven Westra |
| 2000 |
12-6 |
Steven Westra |
| 2001 |
10-10 |
Steven Westra |
| 2002 |
13-7 |
Bill Elgersma (Team was GPAC Conference Champ) |
| 2003 |
13-7-1 |
Bill Elgersma |
| 2004 |
16-6-1 |
Bill Elgersma (NAIA Region IV Runner-Up) |
| 2005 |
9-9-2 |
Bill Elgersma (Lost Regional Semifinal) |
| 2006 |
8-10-1 |
Bill Elgersma (Lost Regional Semifinal) |
| 2007 |
10-7-1 |
Bill Elgersma (Lost Regional Semifinal) |
| Totals |
139-82-8 (.624) |
